This painting appears to have been exhibited with the title of Winter in Twachtman’s solo exhibition at J. Eastman Chase's Gallery, Boston, in January 1886, where, as number 7 in the catalogue, it was one of two winter scenes on view (the other was probably Winter Landscape with Barn, OP.732). Its presence can be verified by descriptions in reviews. A critic for the Boston Evening Transcript wrote that the work shown depicted “a waste of white snow, a wheel track, deep-rutted, sinuous, stretching away to a group of farm buildings, with low hills in the distance.” The Boston Daily Advertiser reviewer saw the work as “extremely subtle and refined.” In the painting, Twachtman's view was across a flat snow-covered landscape (probably a frozen river), broken by carriage tracks that narrow gradually toward isolated far-off farm buildings. The painting evokes the experience of being on a road newly forged by carriage tracks, where shelter and human contact are still far away, heightening the traveler's awareness of the distance yet to be traveled.
It is possible that this was the painting, A Winter Road near Paris, lent to Twachtman's 1907 exhibition at the Lotos Club (1907–I Lotos Club) by Frederic B. Pratt (1865–1945), an American heir who was president of the Pratt Intitute from 1893 to 1937. An article about the exhibition in the Art Bulletin related it to The Torrent (OP.1136) commenting: "We find this same subtle quality in ‘A Winter Road near Paris,' lent by Mr. F. B. Pratt, where a few strong lines say so much."[1]
[1] Art Bulletin 1907.
In its formal experimentation and sophisticated use of atmospheric space, Along the River, Winter teeters on the edge of abstraction. The scene is deliberately ambiguous. The jagged tracks in the snow may lead to an outlying building on the artist's Connecticut farm, but the lack of specificity is the point. Twachtman seems more interested in expressing the silent desolation of winter than in painting a legible landscape.
- Museum website (high.org)