John Henry Twachtman Catalogue Raisonné
An online catalogue by Lisa N. Peters, Ph.D., in collaboration with the Greenwich Historical Society
Print this page
« previous // return to Works // next »

Catalogue Entry

enlarge
Related Work
loading
Keywords
E.702
Mill in Holland
Alternate titles: Weeds and Mill, Holland; Wild Flowers and Windmill, Holland
ca. 1885
Etching on paper
5 x 6 5/8 in. (12.7 x 16.8 cm)
[Signed below plate, lower right, by the artist's son Alden: JHT per AT]
Provenance
Literature
Thorpe, Jonathan. "John H. Twachtman." Arts 1 (October 1921), p. 9 ill. in b/w, as Weeds and Mill, Holland.
Wickenden, R[obert] J. The Art and Etchings of John Henry Twachtman. New York: Frederick Keppel, 1921, pp. 7 ill. in b/w, 28, 47, as Weeds and Mill, Holland.
Baskett, Mary Welsh. "Prints." In John Henry Twachtman: A Retrospective Exhibition, by Richard J. Boyle, Mary Welsh Baskett, and Philip R. Adams. Cincinnati: Cincinnati Art Museum, 1966. Exhibition catalogue (1966 Cincinnati Art Museum), p. 32, as Wild Flowers and Windmill, Holland.
Baskett, Mary Welsh. John Henry Twachtman: American Impressionist Painter as Printmaker—A Catalogue Raisonné of His Prints. Bronxville, N.Y.: M. Hausberg, 1999, pp. 98–99, ill. in b/w, as Mill in Holland. (Baskett concordance).
Commentary

This etching represents the same subject as the pastel Landscape with Windmill (P.705). Twachtman focused in on the most significant elements in the pastel, using line instead of color for the the water flowing through the marsh and the single windmill silhouetted against the sky. Here, however, he cropped the composition more closely, bringing the wildflowers nearer to the viewer. He also used a composition closer to a square, giving the windmill a greater presence in the design. The etching also relates to his oil, Windmills (OP.749), the largest of his Dutch works and the culminating painting to result from his visit to Holland in the summer of 1885.

In this etching, Twachtman left fewer accidental bites and scratches in his plate. His assured draftsmanship was probably due to the training he was receiving in figural rendering in Paris. Mary Baskett states: “Both the print and related pastel, with their depiction of the flat Dutch horizon line, emphasis on the middle ground, subject matter, and fluid draughtsmanship, are reminiscent of Rembrandt’s landscape etchings.”

The impression in the Hood Museum of Art, illustrated here, is a posthumous etching. It was among nineteen etchings reprinted for the 1921 exhibition at Frederick Keppel and Company, New York. According to Baskett, it was probably printed by Peter Platt, a professional printer who produced etchings for Childe Hassam and John Sloan. 

Selected Literature

From Wickenden 1921

In Weeds and Mill, Holland, the group of the old wind-mill and surrounding buildings are effectively placed, the extended vertical sail rising lightly in the sky. Contrary to the usual custom, this more distant group has been more deeply bitten and accentuated than the finer mass of light fragile weeds in the foreground and yet each holds its proper place in the perspective plane. Space, air, and distance have been indicated with the fewest possible lines—a feat that would have pleased Rembrandt [p. 28].